• HOME
  • About
  • CLIENTS
  • PROJECTS
Constance Dykhuizen
  • HOME
  • About
  • CLIENTS
  • PROJECTS

Trafficking in Trafficking

Okay, I’ll bite. I was actually going to write about this last month but I honestly couldn’t get past the first sentence I wrote, partly in jest, which was “Amazon probably isn’t shipping babies. Shipping babies is very expensive.” If you don’t know what I’m talking about, then you might want to ignore this one. There is a gallows humor that comes with working in anti-trafficking. Being in meetings 9-5 about child exploitation, having coworkers watching basically sexual abuse happen on their computers (for investigations) and storyboarding families trafficked across borders to work in strawberry farms makes the chatter kind of nuts as you gather with coworkers for drinks after work. As you might know, I worked in anti-trafficking organizations on and off in Thailand and in the US since 2008. I’ve interviewed adult and child survivors of labor and sex trafficking, police investigators and social workers to raise awareness and support for the realities of what trafficking is like and what it takes to put lives back together.

If you are bewildered by the uptick in talk of trafficking in your feed, wondering if trafficking itself is rising or if it’s just the perception of it, it’s hard to say. The global pandemic made communities that already experienced trafficking even more vulnerable. I’ve heard from partners that kids are dropping out of school and that child marriage is up (which is included in the global total of 40.3 million estimated to be living in trafficking). Borders are closed, so cross-border labor trafficking is more difficult, but online sexual abuse is up. The data since the pandemic is hard to know, but I have seen this panic about sex trafficking, the conspiracies about sex trafficking specifically, creeping up for awhile now.

Trafficking being used to distract from other things, a (partial) timeline:

2016: Pizzagate. If you don’t know, you’re lucky. If you want a refresher, read this.

2017: I got an email from a well-funded anti-trafficking organization offering a print of a painting for a donation. Go ahead. Click on it. I’ll wait. Did you see it? DID YOU SEE IT? Co-opting the liberation of enslaved people by enslaved people through the historical underground railroad and turning it into a literal campaign for white saviorism. I include this slide in my trainings on storytelling ethically for nonprofits, and I think it’s relevant here because it shows a desire for crusading vigilantes to be equated with, and even worshipped as, child savers.

2019: The director of that same organization went on the news shows advocating for the border wall and, ostensibly, for the separation of children from adults at the border in the name of protecting them from trafficking. It has not been proven that there was child trafficking happening en masse at the southern US border.

2020: Wayfair trafficks kids in armoires. Amazon trafficks babies them in NFL backpacks. These aren’t a) efficient b) true c) both a and b. If you guessed c, you’re right. But people I know, even people I have met in the course of anti-trafficking work, have posted these things as truths, or as shadowy warnings of truths, on Facebook. And QAnon is taking over well-intentioned efforts to #savethechildren by the actual organization Save the Children. This article summarizes it well.

The QAnon strategy of pushing some unobjectionable, often factual content about human trafficking in addition to wild conspiracy theories has blurred the lines between legitimate anti-trafficking activism and partisan conspiracy mongering. Recently, some activists have marched in cities around the country demanding an end to child exploitation. Among them were QAnon believers, toting signs with messages like “Hollywood Eats Babies.”

Anti-trafficking has been co-opted, both online with hashtags and viral content and IRL at protests, to distract from real life issues and events. Using trafficking of children as a political weapon or as a means to distract from elections, black lives matter movements or immigration debates is SO GROSS. Why are they doing it? I really couldn’t tell you. Was this done intentionally? I think so. It’s hard to criticize someone who says they are crusading on behalf of children. People are even coming for Tom Hanks as a trafficker. Coming for Tom Hanks just shows that these people are not really interested in solving the problem of trafficking. There is way more low-hanging fruit than Tom Hanks. Give a kid a scholarship and leave Tom Hanks alone. The man had Covid for crying out loud and even donated his plasma. They are interested in clicks and whipping people up into a frenzy about trafficking. Here’s the thing, TRADING ON THE LIVES of children, real or imagined, is exploitation too. I very much believe that some anti-trafficking organizations are guilty of exploitation in the form of sharing survivor stories for profit, trading on the very real suffering of people for the very promising donor dollars that follow. And so many well-meaning people are expending their energy and effort in self-righteous anger and not meaningful actions. The NYT article did said some organizations have experienced an increase in donations, so all is not lost. And I am glad that people are passionate about protecting children. But letting it be a distraction, letting the trafficking of trafficking happen on your feed is counterproductive. Solution-oriented change is needed: Talk to your partners and sons and daughters about buying sex and sex material. It’s not just someone else’s husband buying sex or someone else’s kid selling his girlfriend’s pictures online. Know the difference between pornography (consenting adults) and child sexual abuse material (any sexually explicit content featuring a minor). Foster a child. Read and listen to survivors like Sophie Otiende and Brooke Axtell. Invest in policy change and legal challenges to slavery and prevention programs. There is much to be done. Message me if you want to get involved and we can find something that fits your abilities and interests.

If you need me you, can find me buried under a pile of chihuahuas to try to spark joy.

Friday 08.14.20
Posted by constance dykhuizen
 

The mouth of a shark

Today is World Refugee Day. It’s not like you say “Happy Refugee Day,” but I did want to honor my friends who are current and former refugees. Since I’m in Thailand right now, I talked to my friend who is a young Afghan man currently awaiting refugee resettlement in Bangkok, Thailand about what makes someone decide to leave and the consequences of that decision. His answers reminded me of a Warsan Shire poem Home that I referenced last year on this day - “no one leaves home unless home is the mouth of a shark.”

When did you decide you had to leave home?

April 2016 I was going to my hometown from Kabul to Jaghori district, unfortunately I was arrested by Taliban terrorist group from highway. I was in their cell for 3 days. the evening of third day I had opportunity to flee from their cell and go among the trees and then climbed to the mountain and then went to near the road and take taxi to go to Kandahar then to Pakistan the decision I made to leave my country was taken suddenly not planned.

You didn't intend to come to Bangkok - how did you end up here?

I didn't know anything about Thailand especially Bangkok. I found smuggler from Pakistan to take me to Indonesia but he brought me to Bangkok it was supposed to take me to Indonesia but smuggler release me in Bangkok and he left me I couldn't find him to take me to Indonesia then I didn't have any options. I searched for UNHCR office in Bangkok so I registered here in Bangkok.

What does it mean for you to be a refugee? What does being a refugee feel like?

Being a refugee is like being a slave and it doesn't have good feelings. I had really bad times when I first came to Bangkok. For several days I was sleeping beside the road on the path in the hottest month of Thailand (May), because no one willing to give me a room even I was willing to give money more then usual but they was asking documents and I didn't have any legal documents until I got my UNHCR ID.

How do you spend your days in Bangkok?

For now I'm doing ok in Bangkok. I tried to learn English language and now I'm doing interpreter job for other refugees I know my English skills are not the best but still can help others and can get some money to survive here. Unfortunately UNHCR doesn't support me financially so I need survive myself. And I'm doing some subtitles works beside my interpreting.

People ask me why refugees waiting a long time cannot or will not go home. What is Afghanistan like today?

I think every one likes to live in his/her home if they are safe. Unfortunately Afghanistan situation is getting worse every day. But the government report the situation good to western supporters countries. government doesn't want to show the reality to western supporters countries. If they show the reality then western countries will stop their support, because even the millions dollars spent in Afghanistan but situation is getting worse not better.

What do you hope?

I hope I can get resettlement as soon as possible. Because I need to make my new life. So if I don't get resettlement soon then it will late to make my new life. Finally I realized that humanity is still alive. I realized there is still some angel they are help needy people we are thankful of that people I hope I can give back what they gave me during this time. 

Wednesday 06.19.19
Posted by constance dykhuizen
Comments: 3
 

Great Society Podcast

gs white.png

I have a podcast! You can subscribe, ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️, listen and learn on iTunes (or wherever you get your podcasts). There is also a video version on YouTube if you’re into that.

With Great Society, I was most interested to learn from friends in the social impact space about why they felt called/invited/qualified to do the work of making society more equitable and just. I have been so impressed talking to friends who founded their own movements and those who inherited a vision and made it their own. From artists to social entrepreneurs to global crowdfunders, my guests will inspire you to get involved or think about the work you do differently.

Monday 04.01.19
Posted by constance dykhuizen
 

A Line Birds Cannot See

ALBCS.jpg

A film I helped produce was accepted to SXSW film festival and will premiere in March 2019! See the film’s website for more info on screenings or to watch a trailer.

Wednesday 02.27.19
Posted by constance dykhuizen
 

How I learned to stop worrying and love the bomb

I moved to Thailand for the first time 10 years ago. Newly married, newly graduated from grad school. I was going to save people (children! from sex trafficking!), but, little did I know, I was about to be in need of saving.

On the day my husband Phillip and I moved to Thailand, a state of emergency was called in Bangkok, but I didn't know what that meant. I was engrossed with American politics and this woman John McCain picked for his VP candidate. There was low level unrest and politics mentioned in the local papers, but it seemed contained. And, after all, it wasn't my country.  

On October 7, 2008, I went to work at my new Bangkok office. I vaguely paid attention as people talked about some escalation that day in the weeks-long mass protests. My husband and I were staying at a guest house nearby and, after work, decided to go walk around and see part of it on our way to dinner. We were both naive, but, then again, families were out with baskets of food and there were massage stations set up. Even though they were demonstrating in the thousands, all wearing yellow, which was kind of intense, there was a band. There was free swag. It felt like a color coordinated music festival. Kids and grandmas and signs and people smiling to us, saying thank you to us for being there. Until the tear gas started, it was a real good time. We've since learned from Wikileaks and other sources that there was an attempt to force a coup. (Some of) the yellow shirt demonstrators had (allegedly) tried to provoke a police overreaction so that the military would step in to restore order and overthrow the government. And here I was singing along to John Denver or whatever, totally oblivious. 

The police shot tear gas canisters into the crowd, except, wouldn't you know it, I got the wrong kind. Did you know there's different types of tear gas? I sure didn't. After the fact, they later did some forensic tests (televised, cause Thailand) and, holy cow, I'm glad I didn't get the Spanish-made kind. On the TV, the Spanish kind landed, spewed and then burst into flames. I got a Chinese-made kind that had just a tad too much RDX to make them explode.

There was a flash and an explosion ripped through my body. My ears rang. My eyes stung. I thought it was just the effects of the gas that rattled me, but, as my husband ran and grabbed my hand, he gestured down to a trail of blood. My ankle had been ripped open and my toenails were black and melted. Oh. 

That day, the police used teargas, ostensibly for crowd dispersal, that killed one woman and left one man with no legs. Dozens were wounded. I was the only foreigner.

·

Two men, god bless them, picked me up and carried me away from the scene. I cry just thinking about them. I had come to save Thai people and they literally saved me from danger. They carried a white woman in the midst of chaos who was twice their size and seizing in shock. There was a triage tent where we took stock of ourselves. My husband was dazed but unhurt. We realized that, in addition to my right lower leg, I was missing a chunk from the back of my upper left leg as well. I was put into a van and driven for a bit. And then I was transferred to an ambulance. No idea what was happening or would happen next. 

I was taken to a government hospital, stripped half naked (insult to injury), hosed down with a green garden hose (contaminants from tear gas) and given an injection. Shivering, I was wheeled into an elevator, where I promptly threw up from whatever they injected me with. You don't realize how long elevator rides are until you're riding in one with your own vomit.

They put me in the VIP room. My whole surreal hospital stay was a weird mix of Thais trying to apologize to me in the form of over the top gestures but no actual information. 

I couldn't sleep from pain and shock all night; they had to wait until the morning to perform surgery cause some levels were low. The next morning, they were going to clean out my legs using only local anesthesia until I threw an absolute fit, begging them to knock me out. I just wanted to not be awake anymore. I had surgery that day and once more a week after because of infection. And then I stayed in the hospital. And stayed. And stayed. 

Unhelpfully (and maybe a little unhinged like) I was obsessed with the pieces of my leg that were no longer in my leg. I would lie in bed and wonder -- where are they now? Where did they go? Are they just lying there in the gutter? Did someone come across them and recognize them as human flesh? In retrospect, this is ridiculous. But I also still wonder where those pieces of my leg went. 

The Prime Minister visited me. He brought a giant basket of waxy fruit. He pretended not to speak English and had his interpreter talk to me instead. I was high as a kite and asked him how he liked his new job. On the day of my accident, he had to escape the protesters outside a cabinet meeting by climbing out a window. There were four prime ministers in Thailand in 2008; the one who visited me lasted less than two months. He never did answer my question. 

A TV camera crew came and interviewed us in the hospital and set the whole thing to super sad, dramatic music. They even found footage of me in the triage tent somehow, which was super unnerving. The only politics I wanted to wade into was that I wished they would stop using that kind of tear gas on all protesters, and I said as much. Phillip and I looked just awful. We had like two changes of clothes and his hair was long and shaggy. Watching it later I thought, look at those two idiots. 

Two guys in suits from the US State Department visited and, unhelpfully, asked why I didn't register at the Embassy upon my arrival a month ago. I did get them to agree to mail my ballot it for me from the embassy. That's how I voted for Barack Obama -- from my VIP hospital room in Bangkok.  

HIPA is not a thing in Thai hospitals. Not for my doctors, anyway. I guess consent isn't really a thing either. My psychiatrist took my mother aside and told her not to tell me, but he had me on psychiatric drugs because it was better for me that way. Then he asked her if she knew any of the San Antonio Spurs and if she could get him a signed basketball. 

An Australian lady who visited me with her guitar saw me as some sort of freedom fighter. She sang to me earnestly, with eyes closed, a song she had written about her love for the King of Thailand. She left me a propaganda DVD, which I made the mistake of watching one night when I was alone. To my horror, I realized it was footage from that night and they showed the man who lost his legs, sitting up, dazed, with nothing where his legs were but open wounds since they had just been blown off. 

I spent Halloween in the hospital. It being my favorite holiday, I had to celebrate somehow. I put on butterfly wings and visited the children's ward with candy. I could barely walk, but I reverse trick or treated, knocking on doors and giving out candy to kids. I think I just succeeded in scaring the shit out of them, which is technically part of Halloween, but I much prefer the Martha Stewart version. The kids I visited got sicker and sicker, until I couldn't stand to go in the rooms anymore. I broke down in tears, reminded of the years my younger brother spent in and out of hospitals. Now I was a limping, sobbing woman passing out candy. Happy Halloween!

I should note that the Queen of Thailand paid for my hospital stay and treatment. She was a patron for those of us injured on that day. She sent ladies in waiting to visit me and they were so lovely and kind. My mom tried to contact my insurance company about my expenses, but they rejected it out of hand on account of it being "terrorism-related." A few months later, I would see King Rama IX and the Queen drive by in a motorcade, and I would cry out of gratitude. 

I was released from the hospital on November 11. All told, I spent 35 days there.

·

My PTSD had a soundtrack. Every time I had an episode, I would curl into a ball and listen to Bon Iver to calm me down from my hyperventilating. Everywhere I went I had to have headphones because, surprisingly enough, you just never know when there will be explosions in Thailand. I first had an episode on December 5, the King of Thailand's birthday. It had been two months, and I thought I was FINE. I was religiously massaging my scars with colloidal silver and balms and creams every night, taking care of my physical body, moving on, doing FINE. But the first time I heard fireworks, I lost. my. shit. And I had no idea what was happening. It would be months before I realized or admitted to myself that what I had was PTSD. 

That's another thing - even though it caused “episodes,” I very deeply resented (okay, still resent) the "D" in PTSD. Disorder? How is it disordered behavior to be afraid of the thing that tried to kill you? It seems incredibly logical to me. I think people with PTSD are just woke. We're woke to the fact that everything is trying to kill you. We see what everyone else does not -- that the very earth you stand on can turn on you, that you can't trust that it's a firework and not an IED, that you can't take for granted that a police riot line is there for your protection. We recognize where the threats come from. I think it should be PTSWTF aren't you scared of this too? You should be. 

·

I'm not okay. Ten years ago, this was the hardest thing for me to admit to myself. My husband basically dragged me to go to therapy. 

I was so embarrassed and ashamed to even have PTSD. I got to keep my legs! I didn't see combat or witness anyone get beheaded. I basically got blown up at a picnic. I should be fine. Who am I, a privileged person who had one tiny incident, who am I to absolutely fall apart at my first instance of trauma. I worked with trafficking survivors; they don't have the luxury of falling apart, of therapy. I was even ashamed to have been hurt at all -- what was I even doing there? I knew nothing about Thai politics. It wasn't a political act that got me there; it was only curiosity. 

Though I was incredibly dubious, therapy helped. I went through EMDR (eye movement desensitization reprocessing), which is good for simple trauma (not repeated or prolonged), and it totally changed me immediately. Before, the memory was me. I lived it every day. Afterwards, it was like I could take the memory out in a box and look at it, circumspect and removed from it.

It was years before I started researching trauma and PTSD. Sebastian Junger had an article in Vanity Fair that helped me a lot. He even confirmed my suspicion that PTSD is kind of good for you, or, at least, that it makes sense:

From an evolutionary perspective, it’s exactly the response you want to have when your life is in danger: you want to be vigilant, you want to react to strange noises, you want to sleep lightly and wake easily, you want to have flashbacks that remind you of the danger, and you want to be, by turns, anxious and depressed. Anxiety keeps you ready to fight, and depression keeps you from being too active and putting yourself at greater risk.

He goes on quote studies about how modern-day combat veterans are experiencing PTSD at higher rates than vets of previous wars. Even drone pilots who don’t see combat are experiencing PTSD. So what is it that gives us this debilitating superpower? Junger concluded that it’s not the severity of the trauma experienced, but the isolation and lack of social support that can determine whether or not someone will have PTSD. This was so completely and totally validating to me. And it makes sense and puts my experience into context given that, just a month for the event, I had moved to a new country, knew no one and did most of my ‘healing’ alone. I didn’t know anyone, I didn’t need anyone. I was FINE.

·

I tell you all of this for a reason. After this, after the violence and the trauma and the healing from trauma, I was forever changed. Not just my scars, but the way I relate to other people who have survived trauma and violence. I have a new language and empathy that is real and no longer forced. I cried with a friend from Iraq about an IED she lived through, and I felt it. When I work with refugees who are coming down from the trauma of years in camps or fleeing from violence, I know a little, just a taste, of what it's like to feel shame for having lived through something. Or to hate yourself for how you reacted to it. I feel like one of the most important things I can do as someone who went through this is to help friends process trauma so they can feel supported and not isolated. You don't have to experience trauma to relate to people, of course, but I'm so grateful for my experience now. It's become a cherished part of me, in a weird way. 

People can survive, be survivors of, so many things. These last few weeks have proven that survivorship is a powerful thing. I have not experienced sexual assault, but I do know how trauma changes you. I know that I blame myself for my "accident" (what I call it now, because people look at you funny when you say you got hit by a bomb) and that I even blamed myself for my reaction to it. I put off counseling because I was FINE. Perversely, shame is deep for people who are victimized by something they can't control. 

Even in all this, I must acknowledge my privilege (medical care! counseling!) and the contained nature of my experience. I'm not conflating my trauma with that of sexual assault survivors or refugees. But it is still mine. I get to say what it was and what it felt like. I want that for others as well. I used to have a bombiversary -- it was very important for me to have a space to commemorate this thing that changed me so profoundly. I haven't held one for years, though. It felt silly and indulgent after awhile. Today, my 10th, I've decided, is my last bombiversary. I won't say I'm healed or that it's done with me (there was a pretty bad episode during Diwali in a Delhi hotel room in 2011 and 2017 NYE in Manila was spent under the covers). Besides, I still maintain that my PTSD kept me vigilant and helped me stay alive. I went back today to where it happened in Bangkok, for the first time since that night of the color-coordinated-music-festival-protest-police-crackdown-shit-show. It still feels like the violence was random. That there was no grand plan or design, only a crummy thing that happened to an uninformed tourist in other people's politics. What healed me was in part the surgeries and the doctors and the fruit baskets and the family and friends who messaged and sent gifts. But it was also admitting that I wasn’t fine. And that I needed others. In recognizing my need for others, I recognize that I play a part in the recovery and healing of others.

Sunday 10.07.18
Posted by constance dykhuizen
Comments: 4
 

Nice for What

Last weekend, I went to a citizenship ceremony in Austin for some of the newest Americans. The new naturalized citizens were refugees from Bulgaria, Burma, Cameroon, China, Congo, Eritrea, Iraq, Nigeria, Nepal, Pakistan and Somalia. After five years, refugees are eligible to take the citizenship test and become U.S. citizens. These fourteen people had done just that. They stretched across the first aisle of the makeshift court with a judge presiding from the stage as they rasied their hands for the oath. Shining, smiling faces. Waving flags. Lifting peace signs. Me, clapping and crying in the audience. Someone asked me, do you know someone up there? Er, no. But then again, I do know them. In a way, I know all of them. I have seen how hard life is as a refugee. The waiting and waiting and waiting for resettlement. Friends trafficked from Eritrea and Congo have told their stories of smugglers, traffickers, organ harvesters, rapists, jails. I've also swam in the clear, warm waters of Cuba. I've walked the green foothills of the Himalayas in Nepal. I have tasted the natural beauty and human tragedy of many of their countries. They left behind persecution and violence and corruption, but also mothers and memories and holidays and a land that will never be theirs again. That ceremony was a happy culmination, a symbolic end to so much suffering, but also a severing of identity and family and belonging. Their quest for belonging and acceptance begins anew. They are proud to be Americans, but they are refugees. And America, right now, is not kind to refugees. 

·

A friend recently rudely pointed out that, while I was in Thailand the last few years, I only posted on International Women's Day (so, not rudely, more like accurately). The implication being, I think, that I don't post enough and that I am weirdly attached to random activist holidays. Well, today is world refugee day, and here we are. Perversely, I wish this could be a day to simply focus on the tragedy, humanity and hope of refugees. But it's not even as simple as that any more. I DON'T EVEN GET ONE DAY TO YELL AT PEOPLE ABOUT REFUGEES. When asylum seekers are attacked, when the immigration system is being dismantled, refugees, too will suffer. Are suffering. 

The steady drum beat of dehumanization goes like this... "they're not sending their best." Muslim ban. Lower the refugee quota. "Shithole countries." "The United States will not be a migrant camp, and it will not be a refugee holding facility." Is it even possible to make that decree under international laws and conventions that the US has subscribed to? Oh wait, hold up. We left the UN Human Rights Council? My bad, never mind. Turns out we can do whatever we want. As long as what we want is to slowly chip away at the idea that some people are people. Things are, incredibly, worse than last year. 

Let's talk white privilege. It's a misdemeanor to illegally cross the border the first time. A MISDEMEANOR. As a teen and as an adult doing "missions," I was taught to lie on visa applications to places like India and at border crossings to Mexico because I was allowed to break some laws as a Christian, specifically the laws of other countries. The workplace raids to arrest undocumented people haven't included punishment for businesses that employ them. I know (white) Americans who personally employ undocumented people at great personal benefit. This isn't strictly about criminality and security. Even if it was, what a weird and unproductive fixation. Undocumented people commit less crimes than Americans.

Let's talk why people leave home. Poet Warsan Shire -- "no one leaves home unless home chases you." Here are reasons that my friends left their homes: kidnapped by the Taliban, targeted by an IED outside their home in Baghdad, forced into military service and trafficked for organs and sex, their government has raped and killed and burned their villages because they don't have a right to exist. Would you commit a misdemeanor to get out of those situations? I would commit a misdemeanor for FUN.

People who seek asylum or refugees who have proven to have a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group deserve to be taken seriously and be protected. They are not criminals. They are due a hearing, a process. Children being separated from parents is so ludicrously, cravenly political I won't even address it. I, unfortunately, haven become used to kids in jail. Week after week, I visited the Immigration Detention Center in Bangkok and watched young children grow up behind bars. Their skin grew sallow, the light in their eyes dimmed. We need to end child detention worldwide. 

I want today to be about the success of that ceremony on Saturday. About the joy on the faces of those new Americans. I want to honor the patience and sacrifice of my friends awaiting resettlement. I have to believe that there is a place in this world for them. There must be. Because if there is not a place for my friends to escape to, there is only darkness. 

Wednesday 06.20.18
Posted by constance dykhuizen
Comments: 1
 
Newer / Older